Oakton Coins and Collectibles is one of the most highly rated coin shops near Barrington

We are interested in buying every type of gold, from classic yellow and white jewelry to modern designer items and heirloom estate pieces. Even if your jewelry is broken, damaged, or out of style, it still holds value. We also purchase dental gold, as well as gold in every purity level, including 10k, 14k, 18k, 22k, and 24k. Bullion made of gold or silver is always welcome, and we also provide complete appraisals for pieces containing precious stones such as diamonds, sapphires, or emeralds, ensuring their full worth is recognized.

If you are looking for a fair and friendly place to sell your coins, you have found it here.  Oakton Coins & Collectibles can guide you through the complex process of selling your collection.  If you are a seasoned coin collector, or if you just inherited a collection, we are here to help.  Whether you have one coin or whole collection, our staff offers both their numismatic knowledge and courteous service. Oakton Coins is a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) and a PCGS Authorized Dealer.

How to Sell Coins around Barrington, Knowing their Worth

Assessing a coin’s worth is no simple task, and consulting with an expert is a must.  There are several factors to consider and much to know.  One of the most fundamental questions is whether the coin is worth more than its face value.   One of the benefits of collecting coins is that often, collectible coins can be worth much more than face value, but that collecting is a personal hobby, so the collection will be a reflection of the collector’s personal numismatic interest. Some collect strictly for value, while others may collect low-value coins for a variety of reasons. Regardless of the size or value of your collection, we can help with an appraisal. 

When deciding to sell there are many options.  Some people decide to divide up their collection with family or only sell the valuable pieces and sell the rest.  While others might sell the entire collection at once or not sell at all, particularly if the value is quite low.  It might be of interest to a young aspiring collector in the family.  

As there are different types of collections, there are different ways to organize coins, but you do not need to organize your collection before you bring it to us.  We do that as part of our appraisal process.  However, if you would like to become better acquainted with a collection by putting in the time and effort to organize it, we recommend using the below groups, since that is how we would sort the coins.

• Gold coins 
• 9o% silver dollars (1878 through 1935) 
• 9o% silver dimes, quarters, and half dollars (1892 through 1964) 
• 40% silver JFK half dollars (1965 through 1970) 
• Lincoln Wheat Cents (1909 through 1958) 
• Buffalo Nickels (1913 through 1938) 
• Jefferson Nickels (1938 and later) 
• All other obsolete U.S. type coins
• U.S. Mint proof and uncirculated sets 
• U.S. Mint commemorative sets 
• Currency and paper money 
• Foreign coins/tokens

If you have inherited a collection and are trying to get an idea or its value, here are some questions you can ask yourself. How much money did they spend on the coins?  How often did they buy?  Are there any records such as receipts and invoices?  Perhaps there is a will or an insurance policy?  

This information is a beginning, but each collection is unique.  Ultimately the value of a coin is what a willing buyer will pay for it. Since the market fluctuates, values go up or down daily. 

Pricing your collection to sell around Barrington.

The prices shown in most consumer guides typically reflect retail values, the amount a collector might expect to pay from a dealer under ideal market conditions. These figures are not always indicative of what you’ll receive when selling, especially if you’re selling to a dealer or wholesaler who must account for resale margins, overhead, and market risk.

If you’re hoping to achieve prices close to retail, you may need to seek out individual buyers who are specifically interested in the coins you’re offering. This approach requires more time and effort, such as marketing, vetting inquiries, and negotiating, but in some cases, it may yield a higher return than selling wholesale.

Terms to Know:  Clickbait Pricing, Real-World Pricing, Melt Value Pricing, Numismatics

Clickbait Pricing
“Clickbait” is web text, images, or articles that are created for click to gain advertising revenue.  Clickbait content frequently distorts numismatic facts, promoting unrealistic expectations and false hope among casual collectors and curious newcomers. It also overlooks critical factors that determine true market value, such as condition, mint year, composition, rarity, and demand.

For those interested in selling or evaluating their collection, it’s best to seek guidance from reputable experts and trusted resources rather than relying on internet hype.

Real-World Pricing

Real-world pricing refers to the actual prices coins have achieved in verified transactions where funds that have genuinely changed hands between buyers and sellers. Unlike speculative listings or inflated estimates, this is the way to gauge a coin’s true market value.  A coin is ultimately worth what a willing buyer agrees to pay and a willing seller is prepared to accept. This dynamic is shaped by tangible factors such as rarity, demand and condition. 

Melt Value Pricing
Melt value refers to the intrinsic worth of a coin, determined solely by its precious metal content. Many U.S. coins minted prior to 1965, particularly dimes, quarters, and half dollars contain substantial amounts of silver, while select coins also include gold. The melt value is calculated by evaluating the coin’s weight and purity against the current market price of the metal itself.

Numismatics

Numismatics is the formal study and collection of coins, paper currency, medals, and other related items.  People who engage in this fiel, known as numismatists, examine and evaluate monetary objects for attributes that go far beyond face value or metal content.

Key factors assessed by numismatists include:

Historical Significance: The coin’s origin, context, and relevance to notable events or eras

Rarity: Limited mintage, survival rate, or unique characteristics

Mint Errors: Unintentional flaws or anomalies that occurred during the production process (not after!)

Physical Condition: Grading and overall preservation, which greatly influence collector interest (grading services require a fee)

Coins with exceptional numismatic qualities such as rare dates, flawless condition, or unique provenance can command values that dramatically exceed their melt value or denomination. These pieces hold special appeal in the collector market and often become treasured artifacts of historical and cultural importance.

Places NOT to sell gold around Barrington

• Jewelry Stores and Pawn Shops – While jewelry stores and pawn shops may seem like convenient places to sell coins, they typically assess value based on metal content, not numismatic qualities. Since the focus is on melt value, collectible coins may be undervalued or go unrecognized altogether.
• Ebay –Online marketplaces like eBay are one selling option, but they come with notable challenges. Listing coins requires time-consuming tasks such as photography, descriptions, and buyer communication including disputes, returns and chargebacks.  Additionally, the selling prices are not your profit since the platforms take a cut of each sale through fees.
  Click here for more information.

Sell gold near me, locally, Barrington
Oakton Coins & Collectibles is located near the 94 West (Kennedy) expressway near downtown Evanston, and less than two blocks from the Oakton stop on the Yellow Line CTA (Skokie Swift). It is convenient and close to Arlington Heights, Barrington, Brookfield, Deerfield, Des Plaines, Elmhurst, Elk Grove Village, Evanston, Franklin Park, Forest Glen, Glencoe, Glenview, Highland Park, Hoffman Estates, La Grange, Lake Bluff, Lake Forest, Lincolnwood, Lincolnshire, Lombard, Morton Grove, Naperville, Northbrook, Northfield, Oak Brook, Oak Park, Palatine, Park Ridge, Portage Park, Prospect Heights, Rogers Park, Schaumburg, Skokie, Wheaton, Wheeling, & Winnetka.